What to Write in a Murder Show Card for True Crime Fans
By Sapling Press | Published: 2026-10-25
Category: How-to Guides
Stuck on what to write inside a murder show card? Here are step-by-step message ideas and tips for true crime fans, plus a real card example.
Quick answer
Write a murder show card message that matches your friend's sense of humor—dark, sweet, or somewhere in between. Start with a shared inside joke about their favorite show, then add a short personal note.
Why a murder show card works for true crime fans
True crime fans love when you acknowledge their niche interest. A murder show card turns a shared obsession into a personal, funny gesture. The key is matching the tone to your friend's style—some fans love dark humor, others prefer a sweeter nod to their favorite shows.
Tone options to consider
You can go funny, sentimental, or completely dry. A funny murder show card message might reference a specific show trope (like "I'm not a serial killer, I just watch a lot of true crime"). A sentimental note could say something like "Thanks for always being my partner in crime-solving." Dry humor works well with a straight-faced line like "Let's hope our friendship doesn't end up on a podcast."
How to write your murder show card message
- Start with a show reference or inside joke: Mention a specific true crime show you both watch, or use a line like 'I'll bring the murder show, you bring the snacks.' Avoid generic phrases like 'crime lover'—true crime fans appreciate specificity. Common mistake: writing a message that sounds like a threat. Keep it light and clearly playful.
- Add a short personal note: After the show reference, add one sentence about why you're sending the card. For example: 'Thanks for always being up for a murder show marathon' or 'This card made me think of our last true crime binge.' Checkpoint: If the card has a printed message (like the murder show card's Valentine's Day line), make sure your personal note complements it instead of repeating it.
- Close with a sign-off that fits the theme: Use a closing like 'Stay sleuthy,' 'Case closed,' or simply 'Your favorite accomplice.' Avoid overly formal sign-offs like 'Sincerely'—they clash with the playful tone. Common mistake: forgetting to sign your name. A themed sign-off is fun, but your friend still needs to know who sent it.
Card examples to inspire your message
- murder show card: This card reads 'In honor of Valentine's Day, I'll let you pick the murder show.' It's letterpress printed on ecru cotton paper with a red envelope and black ink. The blank inside lets you write your own message, making it easy to personalize for a true crime fan without being stuck with pre-printed text.
murder show card
